I would venture to say that I read more about beer than the average cat, but by no means would I say I am an expert on the matter. Everyday I scan the beer blogs and tweets for new beer news. Today after reading a bit, a question popped into my head:
What makes a "Japanese Beer" or a "Japanese Brewer"?
For sure I write a lot about beer in Japan, most of it being what I would call Japanese Beer. I guess until today I had never really thought about what a true Japanese beer really is. If you asked most people who know a bit about beer to name a Japanese beer, most would probably say Asahi, Kirin, Sapporo, and maybe even Suntory. For sure these are Japanese companies that make a lot of beer, and most of the people that work for these companies are Japanese. But do they make Japanese beer???
I know you don't need another history lesson telling you about how Europeans came to Japan about 200 years ago and with them brought their brewing techniques. It is the same with most places outside of Europe. If you are drinking beer just about anywhere in the world, it's a safe bet to say that said beer has its roots in someone from Europe.
Are we going to call every beer made in Japan, Japanese beer? Is everyone who makes beer in Japan for a Japanese brewery, a Japanese brewer? Or is that term only going to be reserved for the ethnically Japanese?
I have heard some folks give breweries like Baird a hard time for not being TRULY Japanese. I find this laughable. Are the beers made by Bryan Baird and Chris Poel 'less Japanese' because they are non-natives? Would a beer made with Japanese mikans using the Japanese work ethic by a non-native be less Japanese than a boring Alt made by a native?
Do Bryan and Chris (and Scott Brimmer and other non-native brewers out there living in Japan) not get to be considered Japanese brewers because they don't look Japanese?I remember talking with Bryan Baird in the past and hearing him mention how he is more Japanese than many of their other brewers out there who are brewing the status quo.
I agree.For me, a Japanese beer is one made here in Japan with the spirit, pride, and passion of this country. For sure Japanese beer abounds. Even breweries like Kirin, and Asahi (who we give a hard time) are making a quality product that Japanese people can be proud of. (For those who don't believe me, check out how much a "premium" 6 pack of Asahi costs back in the states!) But besides this, this country is full of brewers who are pushing the limits and making Japanese beer. Beers with Mikans, green tea, miso, yuzu, fish, shiso, and many other Japanese fruits are all inventions of Japan.
Maybe it's just me, but I will always choose a Japanese beer made by a Japanese brewer if I am at a good beer joint. Part of the reason could be that I know I will not live in Japan forever, and that I will return home to KY one day where I can get many good American brews. When I am in Japan, I will always reach for the beer made here, over the ones that travel over the oceans.
And if you think that a Shizuoka Summer Ale or a Gotemba Kogen Weizenbock is less Japanese than a ho-hum pilsner made by Naninani-san--just because the brewer isn't 'Japanese'.....
Then I think you are crazy.
I hope I can stir the brewpot with this a bit and get some differing opinions. What say you?
I hope I can stir the brewpot on this one, I really want to. I want to know what everyone out there thinks.